Goat and Monkey compatibility

Goat (Wei, 未) and Monkey (Shen, 申): no named relation.

These are fixed relations among the twelve branches of the Chinese calendar, set out in the classic San Ming Tong Hui (三命通会), written in 1578, quoted below. They describe the signs, not two people: no classic gives a method for matching two people by their signs, so there is no score here.

How the translations are made

What the book says

Goat and Monkey have none of the relations: no harmony, clash, punishment, harm or break. The book has nothing to say about this pair in particular.

Their elements

The Goat is Earth and the Monkey is Metal: Earth feeds Metal.

How much it counts

A sign is one character of the eight in a BaZi chart, the year’s branch. The book reads these relations between the pillars of one chart, and tells the reader to look at the whole chart’s elements first:

Clash and break, three harmony and six harmony: where a chart has them, ask next how its five elements get on. Misfortune may give rise to blessing, and blessing to misfortune.

相冲相破,三合六合,命中有之,即求五行相得何如。或祸中生福,福中生祸

San Ming Tong Hui, volume 3: On the symbolic stars as a whole (总论诸神煞) · source text

Birth years, and 2027

  • Goat: 1931, 1943, 1955, 1967, 1979, 1991, 2003, 2015. In 2027, the Year of the Fire Goat (Ding Wei, 丁未), the Goat is the year’s own sign (Zhi Tai Sui, 值太岁).
  • Monkey: 1932, 1944, 1956, 1968, 1980, 1992, 2004, 2016. In 2027, the Year of the Fire Goat (Ding Wei, 丁未), the Monkey has no clash with the year.

A sign’s year is usually counted from Chinese New Year, between late January and mid-February; BaZi counts it from the Start of Spring, about 4 February. Born in January or early February? You may be the sign before: the sign pages check your date.

Two real people?

Each person’s chart has eight characters, and the same relations run between all of them, not only the two signs. The two-chart page sets both charts side by side, branch by branch, and gives what each chart says about marriage on its own. No score there either.

Compare two charts

Goat with the other signs: Rat · Ox · Tiger · Rabbit · Dragon · Snake · Horse · Goat · Rooster · Dog · Pig.

Monkey with the other signs: Rat · Ox · Tiger · Rabbit · Dragon · Snake · Horse · Monkey · Rooster · Dog · Pig.

All 78 pairs